Print Page | Close Window

who’s got the best hunting knife?

Printed From: The BaitShop
Category: FireArms, et cetera
Forum Name: Knives, Axes, Saws and Other Sharp Things
Forum Description: Keep 'em sharp!
URL: http://www.baitshopboyz.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4083
Printed Date: 26 March 2026 at 17:52
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.10 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: who’s got the best hunting knife?
Posted By: dakotasin
Subject: who’s got the best hunting knife?
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 03:40

decided that i should upgrade my hunting knives a little. been getting by on a couple of buck knives for awhile, now, and think it is time to try something fresh.

so, did a little looking, and it appears that boker has a good reputation. i looked a little deeper and the 2 models that appeal to me most have ceramic blades. does anyone have any experience w/ ceramic blades? i was told they will probably never need sharpening, but they are brittle. boker will sharpen the blades for free, i guess, but they do not warranty the blade against breaking.

any experience w/ boker? does someone have a better suggestion? the blades on my buck knives start getting a little dull after the first deer. i can get thru a 2nd deer, but by then it is in pretty bad shape. i seem to be spending a lot of time sharpening the blade...



-------------
Hunting is not a matter of life or death; it is much more important than that.



Replies:
Posted By: mr mom
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 07:05
 dakota: bk and i have the best. we think.  k-bar   

-------------
mr mom


Posted By: bkcorris
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 07:50
Yeah, I've got a K-bar. Haven't bloodied it yet so can't give a good review on that part yet, but other wise I love it! I think I personally would be a little leary on a 'glass' blade, but what is the price? I suppose it should hold an edge ok, but would be a pain in the butt to sharpen yourself, and I'd hate having to ship it somewhere to get it sharpened.

-------------

Stupid people are like a slinky, they don't serve much purpose in the world but they sure are fun to watch tumble down the stairs!


Posted By: TasunkaWitko
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 08:51
i love my k-bar, but it DOES seem a bit big for deer and antelope the two times i have used it. maybe not enough practice with it yet!

-------------
TasunkaWitko - Chinook, Montana

Helfen, Wehren, Heilen
Die Wahrheit wird euch frei machen


Posted By: dakotasin
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 15:29

the price of the bokers i am looking at start at around $120 and go up.

you don't sharpen the ceramic - it is done w/ a laser, i guess. therefore it must be sent in to be sharpened...but, i've been told that these blades will probably outlast me. don't know if i buy it or not, but that's what i've been told.

k-bars are much bigger than what i want...

i am not sure i am ready to spend this kind of money on a knife... but, the length of time it will hold an edge is appealing, the extreme light weight is appealing, they are the perfect size, balance well, and seem to have some sort of 'stickshun' on the handles so a little bit of blood wouldn't cause a catastrophic slip.

but, before i run out and buy one, i'd kinda like to see what the bsb's input is... k-bar has crossed my mind many times... they are just too damned big. 



-------------
Hunting is not a matter of life or death; it is much more important than that.


Posted By: CB900F
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 15:37

Dakotasin;

Go to google & search these two.  A. G. Russell knives & Smokey Mountain Knife Works.  If one of these two doesn't have it & at a pretty good price, then it's truly hard to find. 

I've heard the same as you about Boker.  Sharp as hell & brittle.  Might want to look at Puma now that they are doing quality work again.  Or if a true custom is what talks to you, look at Randall.

900F



-------------
Birth certificate!? He don't need no steenkink birth certificate!!


Posted By: bkcorris
Date Posted: 31 March 2004 at 15:51
'Traditional' K-bars come in two sizes, the normal 6 1/2" blade is 12" overall, then a short version that has a 5 1/4" blade and 9 1/2" overall. I thought of getting the shorter one but opted for the larger one as it could be used for a lot of things non-hunting related, even a good utility knife for camping. I think I may get a short version one too just for kicks.

-------------

Stupid people are like a slinky, they don't serve much purpose in the world but they sure are fun to watch tumble down the stairs!


Posted By: Teddy
Date Posted: 01 April 2004 at 04:10

I've tried many knives over the years.  My favorite is Golden Spike by Schrade.   Great design and very good steel.  I highly recommend it.  Shop around around a bit on the net and you'll find one for under $40.

Marble's and Kershaw also make some great knives. 

Teddy



-------------
Walk softly and carry a 30-30


Posted By: TasunkaWitko
Date Posted: 01 April 2004 at 04:45

my "go-to" knife is the sharpfinger by schrade. as said above, i love my k-bar and use it or my m7 bayonet for ribcage splitting and other "big" work, but the sharpfinger is the one that goes into the guts.

bkc's suggestion of a "baby k-bar" is worth considering....



-------------
TasunkaWitko - Chinook, Montana

Helfen, Wehren, Heilen
Die Wahrheit wird euch frei machen


Posted By: mtmiller
Date Posted: 01 April 2004 at 15:53

Wow, you guys play with the big blades.  I have never been that impressed with the big blades for field dressing, skinning and caping big game.  I bought a Dunn custom knife in 1995 and love it.  I have found the razor sharp 3" blade to be perfect for reaching in the chest to cut out the wind pipe and perfect for cutting around the anus. 

When I first got it I used it to split the sternum and it worked fine.  Rarely do I split the chest any more as I can usually get a better deal on the capes.

Anyway, my two cents, get a knife that will hold an edge and bigger is not always better.

http://www.dunnknives.com - www.dunnknives.com



-------------
Havre, MT


Posted By: saddlesore
Date Posted: 04 April 2004 at 08:10

There is an old gent by the name of E.J. Smith in Independance , Kansas that is a cattle rancher and makes knives for a hobby, and sells them.

The run $65 including shipping, are deer antler handeled and usually sport a 5-6 inch blade. He grinds them for left or right hand users. I imagine he would make one any size you want.

Mine has lasted through three elk without any touch up. Try one, you will really like them. If you don't like it, I'll buy it from you. These are the best knives I have ever used , especialy for the price. Each one is unique. I have a big and smaller K-Bar, and a Buck Skinning knife. These far surpass any of them

E.J. Smith

Rt 2

Box 285

Independance , Kansas 67301

620-331-5211



-------------
Saddlesore
If God wanted you to walk and carry things on your back, He would not have invented stirrups and pack saddles


Posted By: CB900F
Date Posted: 04 April 2004 at 08:36

Fella's;

Another VERY handy tool is the Gerber pack axe.  I've got one & won't go hunting without it.  It's a very small & lightweight hand axe.  You should be able to find one in any decent sporting goods store these days for under $30.00.  Check it out, you might find yourelf getting one.

900F



-------------
Birth certificate!? He don't need no steenkink birth certificate!!


Posted By: Tikkabuck
Date Posted: 04 April 2004 at 10:08
  I agree with Teddy,I've hunted with alot of knives and still oggle at the newest purty ones when they come out,but so far my favorite is my Buck Crosslok my son gave me,and at one time  during the early 80's I said I'd never own another Buck,(never say never). But truly this is the handest,best edge holding blade I have ever used,I like this one so much I freak when it's not in my pack.

-------------
God,Mother,Country,and Hot Rods. Done with political crap.LOL


Posted By: Teddy
Date Posted: 04 April 2004 at 11:53

Actually, we have it better than ever.  My Dad as a young man never had the selection and competitive pricing we have before us in 2004.

Teddy 



-------------
Walk softly and carry a 30-30


Posted By: SteelyEyes
Date Posted: 13 April 2004 at 15:00
I have the best hunting knife. It's a Gerber 575 with the fancy wood handle. It's a bit scratched and usually has blood stains on it. I've dressed a couple of mountain goats, an unknown number of deer (3 in a day once), and about 10 elk with it. It has good hand feel, it's not too long or two short, it has a good sweep to the edge so you can skin with it, and my wife bought it for me when we first got married. I wouldn't part with it for anything except maybe one day to give it to my daughter. I think she has the hunter's heart moreso than my son and she'd both deserve and respect the gift for all that it is.


Posted By: Eagleye
Date Posted: 19 April 2004 at 20:10
I'm not much for those big blades either. First of all, in this part of the country, only inexperienced hunters carry those machete size knives. I get into much less trouble and have never longed for much more than a 4½" blade. even when working on a large Moose. I'll post a picture of my favorite, a custom made knife by a very skilled local craftman. Holds an edge very well also. Regards, Eagleye

-------------
Never argue with an idiot. They will drag you down to their level & then beat you with experience!


Posted By: Earl
Date Posted: 22 April 2004 at 08:02

 

The very best knife for any outdoors chore is the one your hunting pal has.



Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 22 April 2004 at 09:20

Think we chewed this thread before.

I've got some big showy sheath knifes.  Best for me is the Puma, figure $150 and up.  Holds an edge forever.  I have the White Hunter model, bought in 1961.  I take it to wilderness areas, like Alaska and Africa, where "eat you things" live.

For hunting I love a double bladed folding knife, with a small stone in a soft leather sheath.  Case is very good.  I prefer wood handles as they are lighter than bone, and less slippery.  Checkering is a nice addition after you get the knife. it helpd when you are up to your shoulders in the body cavity.  I get the sheath custom make so it is small and the knife almost falls out of it after you open a snap.

My favorite is an old L.L. Bean double folding with a Rosewood handle.

BEAR



Posted By: kickback
Date Posted: 05 May 2004 at 18:28
I have a knife my father and I made.Green River blade,walnut handle.It will dress about 8 deer before it needs to be touched up with a steel.It's carbon steel so it stains but it is easy to sharpen and it gets so sharp it will scare you.


Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 06 May 2004 at 03:54

Hey, kickback  Welcome.

Nice to hear from you.  Hope you stay on BSB, it is a pretty good place to talk.

Where are you from and what do you hunt?????

Tongue

BEAR



Posted By: quigleysharps45
Date Posted: 08 May 2004 at 21:03
I've had Ernie Grospitch make me a couple. My "Kansas Bowie" is on his site, mines the 2nd. one down, even had him put my initials RW on the handle. The second one he made me is a drop point, sent him my old one to duplicate and put my initials on the handle. Will try to post it. He can fix you right up with a custom knife. He'll work with you to give you what "you" want. He's at http://www.erniesknives.com - www.erniesknives.com


Posted By: Muleskinner
Date Posted: 10 May 2004 at 16:24

This place is gonna get my business real soon.  Something to be said for the Green River style.  Check out the Cliff Knife.

http://www.idahoknifeworks.com/ - http://www.idahoknifeworks.com/



-------------
Mule


Posted By: 7mm Magnum
Date Posted: 21 September 2004 at 12:14

I guess I'll chime in here,...

I too favor a smaller blade on a knife. I've got a GERBER right now that works perfect for my needs. It's a 4" blade folder that has the rear section (last 1 1/2") serrated. It works just great for the grizzle sections like cutting through the sturnum,... and the knife edge seems to stay sharp forever.

I used to use an old BUCK 110 for years but now I have been spoiled with the Gerber.



-------------
Shoot Straight & Stay Safe!
Terry A. Webster

Life Member NAHC
Life Member NAFC
Life Member NRA
Mich. Steelheaders
RMEF Supporting Member
SCI
Veteran US Army 70-72 SGT 1Bn 327th Inf Div



Posted By: Kingpin
Date Posted: 25 October 2004 at 15:50
Personally, I feel that all the above mentioned are very good. One thing that I discovered a few years ago, and it may be available at gun shows or Army Surplus stores is, a field surgeons scalpel. It has a plastic handle, and a safety razor blade folds out. These are very sharp, so if you handle one, be very careful. You WILL cut yourself if you choke up on the small handle. These are disposable, and can be had for about a quarter a piece. I carry several of them at all times, in my glove box, in my hunting kit, and other places for convienience. I usually carry a large knife, like a butchers knife that I made of air hardening steel, and a folding Puma Lieutenant. In truth, the field scalpel is one very item to carry. If you feel the need, you can even shave with one, but very carefully I should hope. They work wonders for gutting, and if you are like everyone else, and lay it down and forget it, you haven't lost anything............Kingpin

-------------
There are times when a normal man must, spit in his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats.


Posted By: Blkpwdernut
Date Posted: 26 October 2004 at 09:09
Try Knives of Alaska, I have the camp knife and the caping knife, it gets it done for me and they are very high quality

-------------
Does not play well with others


Posted By: Muleskinner
Date Posted: 31 October 2009 at 20:21
I used a KOA camp knife for several seasons of quartering elk.  They sharpen up pretty well, but don't hold an edge like I'm used to.  They use a harder steel in their handmade series that is like 61 on the Rockwell.  It sharpens slowly as a consequence, but once you get it, it will hold that edge for numberous critters.

-------------
Mule


Posted By: soggyshooter
Date Posted: 01 November 2009 at 02:11
Mora #840 from Frost's Sweden. Mk-II navy.


Posted By: Muleskinner
Date Posted: 02 November 2009 at 06:07
That's a fine looking knife, quigley.  The handle looks substantial but not too thick.  Good length blade too.  I like drop points made from hard tool steel - thick blade, but not too thick.  Your knife seems to fit the bill nicely.

-------------
Mule


Posted By: VarmintGuy
Date Posted: 21 November 2009 at 06:20

Guys: I am not what you would call a "Knife Collector" but over the decades of my "gun trading" industry - I had accumulated probably 150 knives of the Hunting type and at least 50 more of the street fighting type!

I have and have owned many custom Hunting knives including those by Ruana, Randall, Bjerkle, Morseth and on and on and on!

Last year I decided to start selling off my double, large, drawer full of knives.

I am certain I have realized well over $2,500.00 on what I have sold so far - I immediately bought Hunting Rifles with said monies!

I still have a LONG way to go selling off what I don't use.

NOW to what I do use for Hunting!

My favorite Hunting knife of all time is the simple two bladed large Buck folder Model #317!

This knife has a lanyard hole, is relatively compact and yet exceptionally strong. The 2 blades are 4 1/16" and 3 7/8" long.

One blade is wide and thicker than the other.

I always have "a" sharp blade to fall back on it seems.

The thinner narrower blade is ABSOLUTELY PERFECT for reaming and removing the digestive tract outlet from game animals!

I mean it is PERFECT - I have never seen a better blade for this essential function - EVER. And I have seen a LOT of knives try this operation over the last 5 decades!

This knife has been copied EXACTLY by numerous other knife makers over the years - those knife makers include Puma, Schrade, Western and on and on.

I have several of the "copies" of this Model 317 still today (including those by Pume, Schrade and Western) and I have an "extra" Buck #317 just in case times get tough.

I have never seen a knife (custom or factory!) that gets as much done as quickly and as well as my Buck #317!

I feel I will trim down to about 20 Hunting knives and maybe 2 street fighting knives and never will be tempted (I am sure!) to buy another expensive custom Hunting knife the rest of my life.

My advice regarding custom Hunting knives - the money can be much better spent, in many other places.

Hold into the wind

VarmintGuy

 

 



Posted By: 24mod12
Date Posted: 21 November 2009 at 23:16
I watched many old time hunters use a folding pocket knife to gut all species of game.I bought a Gerber folder and a  Gerber Mini Magnum  sheath knife and used both on squirrels,quail,bandtailed pigeons,grouse,rabbits mule & blacktail deer. When Schrade went under in Ellenville,NY I bought several of their knives on ebay which I kept for myself and gave others to family and a friend.The "new" schrades are chinese made.


Posted By: GOT14U
Date Posted: 22 December 2009 at 08:31
I'll take a schrader "old timer" almost any day of the week.


Posted By: Muleskinner
Date Posted: 23 December 2009 at 16:26

Bark River "Fox River" model is hard to beat.  The tool steel is good, the handles light and the shapes are classic.  Not too expensive, yet.

http://www.knivesshipfree.com/Bark-River-Knives-Fox-River-Knife-Red-Linen-Micarta - http://www.knivesshipfree.com/Bark-River-Knives-Fox-River-Kn ife-Red-Linen-Micarta



-------------
Mule


Posted By: Irish Bird Dog
Date Posted: 29 December 2009 at 17:49
I have a few knives as do most of us shooter types....most of my gun belts have a sheath knife hanging on them but my fall back "hunting" knife is a Buck 110 that I have had for 30yrs maybe.....I carry a Gerber folder w/clip daily & it has a partial serrated blade, general use knife and also a smaller  3 blade pocket knife, a Camillis for smaller general knife needs.  My dad found it laying on USH 2 in N WI many yrs ago & he said he wore out more brakes on the tractor/lowboy when he stopped to pick it up then a pocketful of those knives were worth. 

-------------
Irish Bird Dog

NRA Life/Endowment

2nd Amendment Supporter


Posted By: Irish Bird Dog
Date Posted: 29 December 2009 at 17:51
quigley.......nice looking knife and I like the sheath too.....both look sturdy and well made....... 

-------------
Irish Bird Dog

NRA Life/Endowment

2nd Amendment Supporter


Posted By: chikee
Date Posted: 05 January 2010 at 20:12
I got my husband a Buck knife for a wedding present and had it engraved.  Something witty and meaningful that I can't remember now and our names and wedding date. It was to bring him luck on all of his elk hunts.  He's never taken it out of the gun safe, for fear of losing it.  Maybe that's why he hasn't gotten an elk for two years in a row now.     I'll have to suggest it to him.

-------------
-Chikee


Posted By: JUSTN A. MURKAN
Date Posted: 04 October 2010 at 10:26
I'll take a schrader "old timer" almost any day of the week.

-------------
If,,in the end all I have is my honor......it will be enough!



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 11.10 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2017 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net